Review: Oath to a Withered Star

Oath to a Withered Star by Joseph Young
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

There are many appealing aspects to this book, but collectively they do not make for a good read. The characters appear somewhat caricatured, even those who later develop in real ones, the plot is somewhat confusing, and there are sudden surprises that do not seem to fit in very well. In my opinion, with some good editing, it could have been significantly improved. However, as it stands, I do not believe it will motivate me to read the second part. We shall see.

Ci sono tante cose carine in questo libro, ma tutte insieme non fanno comunque un buon libro. I personaggi sembrano delle macchiette, anche quelli che poi lo diventano, la storia é un po' confusa e poi ci sono improvvisamente delle sorprese che non c'entrano poi molto. Secondo me con un buon editing si poteva salvare parecchio, così com'é peró, non credo mi spingerà a leggere la seconda parte, vedremo.

I received from the Publisher a complimentary digital advanced review copy of the book in exchange for a honest review.

View all my reviews